Nietzsche once wrote, “Without music life would be a mistake.” But I would like to humbly make an addition: Without creative music life would be a mistake.
I may be fatalist and pessimistic, but I have given up on Chinese music. Perhaps I should be more clear. I have given up on a Chinese music industry that churns out pretty faces that only sing love ballads and shun real musicians that push the boundaries of musicianship.
It wasn’t always this way. A few talented, edgy, creative musicians came on the scene and started to get pretty big. There was a glimmer of hope with the raw, gritty, thoroughly-Chinese rock (he plays a gu zheng on stage!) of 谢天笑 (XTX). Then there was the kitschy, upbeat, electro-disco-punk-rock of New Pants (新裤子). And there was Hedgehog (刺猬), with catchy hooks and perhaps the cutest little drummer ever. But there is no hope for acts like these in the Chinese music industry. As big as they seem to be, I’ll bet all of the RMB in my wallet that they all have day jobs.
These diamonds in the rough weren’t enough to give me faith in the Chinese music scene. There are far too many cookie-cutter Ken and Barbie’s with glorified KTV resumes dominating the music industry. The songs they sing are an endless stream of pop love ballads that are hardly distinguishable from one another. With a knack for singing, that’s all they are: singers. There is a fundamental difference between a singer and a musician. Singers sing, musicians make music.
Talking with a Chinese friend about this phenomenon, 王力宏, the ABC-Chinese-Taiwanese pop superstar came up. My friend said, “He writes his own songs,” as if it was an amazing feat. Amazing feat it may be, but citing a New York-born, Berklee College of Music grad to save the face of the whole Chinese music scene is a stretch to say the least.
The simple fact is that the few original, creative musicians in China are being overshadowed and cast out by the music industry that puts lip-syncing pin-up dolls on every TV channel. Not once on Chinese television have I seen a real band playing real music, excluding those 12 girls and the folks that play the Beijing Opera jams (though I have seen bands pretending to play their instruments…imagine that). For now, any musicians with potential are relegated to inaccessible record labels or semi-obscure websites.
So I’ll remain pessimistic, but in the meantime, turn off your TV, dig through underground music, and let me know if anything comes up…